Milburn dodges sensible steps that could cut welfare bill
Getty Images

Milburn dodges sensible steps that could cut welfare bill

Milburn’s recommendations would save just £200 million after 10 years. This won't get the benefits bill under control

The problem doesn’t end with those under-25, and the rise in welfare claimants across age groups has overlapping causes

There is a cap on households benefits, but if one member of the household qualifies for PIP, the cap is set aside

Milburn dodges sensible steps that could cut welfare bill
Getty Images

Share this article

A year in the making, the Milburn review is finally here. Months of debate and speculation gave way to great fanfare as the former Blair cabinet member unveiled his findings. We can certainly expect its ideas and recommendations to be argued over for months or even years to come. One thing’s for sure, though: it’s a massive disappointment for taxpayers.

Set up in the wake of the Labour backbench rebellion over then prime minister Keir Starmer’s proposed welfare cuts (actually just a reduction in the increase of welfare spending), the review supposedly served as a chance to take the politics out of the benefits debate and focus on what needs to be done to get young people into work. A cynic might say it was a chance to kick the can down the road and not deal with one of the biggest issues facing the country. 

And if a week is a long time in politics, a year is an age. Indeed, I suspect that when Keir Starmer and Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, commissioned the report, they didn’t imagine only one of them would still be in their job when it was published.

The idea that only £200m can be saved after 10 years and vast amounts of spending is a damning indictment of just how little impact the recommendations will have. Britain’s benefits and spending addiction has run unchecked for too long.

If establishing a review saved having to make a decision for a year, implementing its recommendations buys even more time before having to actually cut benefits.

Milburn rejects so-called ‘crude cuts’ to benefits while calling for substantial up-front spending. There are plans for new local Youth Opportunity Services, occupational advisers taking responsibility for issuing fit notes and quicker access to mental health services. 

On the other side of the ledger, young people would be moved off Personal Independence Payments (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit (UC), to instead receive a new allowance equivalent to the basic rate of UC. 

All told, Milburn’s recommendations would save just £200 million after 10 years. While any saving is welcome, this is hardly the revolutionary reforms we need to bring the benefits bill under control. After all, according to the Taxpayers’ Alliance own benefits dashboard, the total savings barely cover the yearly benefits bill in Andy Burnham’s own constituency of Makerfield.

Britain’s benefits system is bursting at the seams. Spending on just six benefits reached £133 billion in England and Wales by March this year. Almost 2.5m working-age benefit claimants have no obligation to look for work. Much attention is given to the crisis amongst young people, and with almost a million of them not in employment, education or training, the risk of a lost generation is no exaggeration. It’s right to make it a national priority. But the problem doesn’t end with those under-25, and the rise in welfare claimants across age groups has overlapping causes.

For example, Milburn admitted that the increases to the minimum wage and hikes to employers’ National Insurance by this Government has made it harder for businesses to employ young people but the same is also true for older workers. 

Similarly, the report’s suggestion of cutting employers’ National Insurance for under-25s alongside grants to those employers is simply handing them back some of the money previously taken from them. It is a subsidy to offset the impact of those policies causing the damage. The alternative option of simply reversing those policies, which would also benefit people in other age brackets, appears to be too radical a notion.

Tackling the welfare bill doesn’t have to be this difficult, unless you’re one of the 204 Labour MPs with a smaller majority than the number of people claiming PIP in their constituencies. For everyone else, there are sensible steps that could be taken to bring the bill down and restore fairness for the taxpayers propping the system up. 

While the UK notionally has a cap on the amount households can receive in benefits, if one member of the household qualifies for PIP, the cap is set aside. The cap stands between £14,753 and £16,967 for a single adult and £22,020 and £25,323 for a single parent or couple depending on whether they live in or out of London. Despite this, figures for 2024-25 show that 151,005 households claiming the daily living component of PIP received more than £41,600 annually in state support, including 3,451 single-adult households. Removing the PIP exemption could save up to £7.5bn a year, though other exemptions would prevent the full saving being realised.

Means testing would be another way to bring spending down. In 2024-25 there were 196,883 households who got the daily living PIP allowance despite having a gross income of at least £100,000. Scrapping these payments could save £785m.

One important area Milburn touches on is looking to restrict the ease with which people get signed off due to mental health issues like anxiety or neurological conditions like ADHD or autism. 79% of 16- to 24-year-olds claiming PIP recorded psychiatric conditions as their primary condition, compared to 38% of 25- to 65-year-olds. Preventing these people from being written off and spending a lifetime dependent on the state is absolutely essential. Restricting the conditions that qualify for support and linking any assistance to the real additional costs incurred would ensure that help goes to those truly in need.

Stay informed with our free daily briefing.

Too many of the problems of the benefits system have been ignored by Milburn’s review and the interests of taxpayers have been a secondary consideration at best. The idea that only £200m can be saved after 10 years and vast amounts of spending is a damning indictment of just how little impact the recommendations will have. Britain’s benefits and spending addiction has run unchecked for too long.

Andy Burnham promised honesty and real solutions to the nation’s problems, but this report misses the mark. Refusing to cut spending now just leaves taxpayers once again being told to suck it up, hand over more of their hard-earned cash and trust that it’ll all work out in the end.

Share this article

Written by

Benjamin Elks
Benjamin Elks is Grassroots Development Manager at the Taxpayers’ Alliance.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.