The UK is losing the race to cut red tape



As we head into the Budget, the Government continues to make all the right noises about growth. Yet the policy still falls far short of the rhetoric – as confirmed by the latest GDP figures, which once again painted the picture of a flatlining economy. The gap between rhetoric and reality is nowhere more apparent than in the Government’s recently updated ‘Regulation Action Plan’. Pledges to cut red tape are welcome, but the approach must be more ambitious, proportionate and delivered with far greater urgency.
According to the World Bank Enterprise Survey, senior managers in the UK spend 10% of their time dealing with regulation, which is more than the global average (8%) and double that of the United States (5%). In South Korea and China, the figure is barely measurable: 0.2% and 0.3% respectively.
It also takes 37 days to obtain an operating licence in the UK, compared with 10 in China or 18 in the US. Securing a construction permit takes roughly 100 days here, versus 42 in China and 62 in America.
This bureaucratic drag has measurable economic costs. The Centre for Policy Studies calculated that the recurring regulatory cost to business averaged £57 billion a year between 2010 and 2019. In 2023, the Growth Commission estimated that regulations introduced since 2015 have imposed a negative regulatory impact equivalent to £143bn annually – around 6% of GDP. A few days ago, PwC with TheCityUK estimated that the cost of compliance in the financial sector alone amounts to over £33.9bn, which is equivalent to around 10% of total revenue generated by the sector.
Cutting excessive regulations or simplifying them not only saves time for firms but also releases capital for productive investment. More importantly, it signals that the government is serious about facilitating and nurturing the private sector, boosting business confidence. Together, these benefits drive productivity and growth over time.
The concept is not new. Like previous administrations, this Labour Government has promised to cut the cost of compliance, targeting £5.6bn in savings out of the £22.5bn baseline. However, the Government will need to go further if the regulatory burden is to be meaningfully reduced.
Right from the outset, the baseline looks modest when set against the independent estimates. A recent paper published by my colleagues at the Centre for Policy Studies suggests that the true administrative cost of regulation is far higher than the £22.5bn figure. This means the actual savings promised under the Action Plan would amount to only a small fraction of the total burden. To make a real difference, the ambition in cutting red tape needs to be far greater.
Then there’s the question of scope. While the Action Plan includes reforms ranging from corporate reporting to tax administration and financial regulation, it remains limited in the areas businesses themselves identify as most onerous.
The Business Perceptions Survey 2024 found that 58% of firms identify compliance with employment law and rights as challenging, and nearly nine in 10 mention it is relevant to their operations. However, the reduction plan contains no measures to ease employment law compliance. Worse, the Employment Rights Bill introduces new obligations through guaranteed hours, stricter redundancy procedures, and greater union powers. These interventions will undeniably raise compliance costs, rather than lowering them.
A similar issue appears in taxation. The share of firms finding tax administration challenging has increased from 22% to 29%, including a third of micro and small businesses and more than a third of businesses engaged in innovative activities. To overcome this, HMRC proposed a ‘digital-first’ roadmap through the Action Plan. However, there were no pledges to simplify the tax code or address complexities in VAT, PAYE or IR35. This essentially translates to digitisation of existing complexities rather than simplification.
It is welcome that some reforms in the Action Plan are focused on corporate and financial reporting. For instance, raising company size thresholds by 50% to spare roughly 132,000 firms from complex reporting requirements will reduce the regulatory burden on medium and small businesses. Likewise, the pledge to halve the burden of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) – notorious for paperwork and delay as firms must obtain regulatory approvals for senior appointments and re-certify staff annually as ‘fit and proper’ – also sounds promising.
While these measures address challenges in regulatory compliance (other than tax administration) reported by 38% firms and almost half of innovating businesses, the stakeholders deem the pledged changes to fall well short of the ambition to cut costs by 50%. As TheCityUK notes, the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) proposal to remove duplication in SM&CR would cut less than 15% of total costs, and even then, the implementation risks would be sequential and slow. Moreover, much of the FCA’s pledges appear to be on hiring more staff to help firms navigate the rules, rather than simplifying them.
Even when problems are recognised, urgency is absent. The Government has acknowledged a number of regulatory problems and produced dozens of consultations. Many of these consultations run into 2026 or later and do not focus on immediate relief. The result is that businesses will continue to devote thousands of staff-hours and capital to compliance while waiting for reforms that may or may not arrive. But higher taxes will bite long before lower regulatory costs materialise. So, implementing the reforms should be treated with urgency.
The global economy won’t wait while Britain conducts consultations through 2026. Every month we delay meaningful deregulation is another month capital and talent flow to jurisdictions that understand both urgency and ambition. The Regulation Action Plan needed to slash the £143bn regulatory burden, tackle employment law head-on, and simplify our tax maze. Instead, we got modest targets, glaring omissions and a timeline that suggests the Government still doesn’t grasp that regulatory competition is real, and we’re losing.