The regulator shouldn’t rig your YouTube feed


The way we as consumers engage with news, TV and online media is continually evolving. Traditional TV has been increasingly usurped by streaming services. Apps like YouTube are taking up a greater share of viewers’ time and are now successfully competing with the likes of Netflix. It is natural that in this environment competition is fierce.
The reality is no TV programme has certainty viewers will tune in, or any newspaper that readers will pick up a copy. In practice, independent and commercial media fight for their future every single day. That is why I recently wrote to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) to raise my concerns over Ofcom’s latest recommendations to skew the marketplace in favour of public service broadcasters (PSB) and other favoured broadcasters.
The CMA refused to review Ofcom’s proposals. It told me that Ofcom was ‘best placed to consider the competition implications of its implementation’, and it would not take any action to prevent this market distortion. The CMA’s purpose is supposedly to promote competition. These prominence rules drive a coach and horses through any semblance of the free and open competition our economy is based on. I therefore struggle to understand its unwillingness to act.
Ofcom is trying to decide what people see rather than leaving it to normal people themselves
Ofcom’s proposals for prominence will be enacted through two main routes.
First, Ofcom’s recommendation, now published in a Government green paper, is for video sharing platforms like YouTube to place ‘trustworthy’ content, inevitably focusing on PSBs, prominently on all users’ homepages – and if they don’t comply, to be made to do so by law.
Platforms like YouTube have thrived in large part because the platform adapts to consumer habits, in terms of their programming preferences. Viewers see content on their homepage from media whether commercial, independent or PSB, based on previous choices. It is just wrong for Ofcom to then turn around and basically say: ‘I know this is content YouTube viewers want. However, we have decided what we want you to see is more important than what you want to see.’ This is the opposite of what a free and fair market should be.
We can imagine how this new ‘Ofcom approved’ version of YouTube will disadvantage small, independent creators.
Take for example, an up-and-coming channel that makes children’s entertainment videos and is growing organically. Its growth and revenue will be undermined by CBeebies videos automatically appearing prominently, driving viewers toward the established brand instead.
The same would happen to a cookery channel that is trying to grow by presenting classic recipes, while the platform pushes people towards BBC Good Food. Not because of the relative quality of the offerings. Because someone at Ofcom has decided to make it harder for independent channels to get views and grow, strangling small businesses.
The second major way Ofcom’s proposals will hurt competition is through the visibility of PSB apps on smart TV home screens. The Media Act 2024 already made it a legal requirement that smart TV operators meet PSB prominence requirements, but Ofcom published a consultation in January on its proposed code of practice. Ofcom expects (free of charge, of course) for PSBs to appear in the first nine ‘tiles’ by TV manufacturers on your smart TV homepage. As if that wasn’t enough, when you search for content, you guessed it, PSB content will be placed into prominent positions on search listings.
It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to realise giving them this prominent position is yet another example of Ofcom trying to decide what people see rather than leaving it to normal people themselves. This hurts commercial broadcasters and streaming services, as they effectively will be left to fight over less ‘real estate’ and charged higher fees due to fewer tiles that are available for sale. One TV platform has already told government the opportunity cost of carrying PSB services runs into ‘tens of millions of pounds a year’
This is to say nothing of the potential chilling effects on political discourse resulting from the subtle sidelining of non-establishment broadcasters.
I sympathise with all of those in the media sector, including PSBs trying to navigate a constantly evolving landscape. PSB content provides high quality programming that enriches and entertains us. But that does not mean it requires Ofcom to intervene in such a heavy-handed fashion in their favour. Worryingly the new Ofcom chair, Ian Cheshire, practically boasted to a parliamentary committee that he lobbied for prominence when he was chair at Channel 4.
Britain has a tradition of free, open and fair markets. This tradition has undoubtedly contributed to our economic success. I believe this heavy-handed intervention undermines that strength by distorting the market and privileging a few select, government-approved favourites.
These proposals would result in existing, less-established broadcasters facing greater obstacles to compete in an already fast-moving media landscape, and make market entry more difficult. This means, at a time when people are losing faith with traditional mainstream media, the drawbridge is being pulled up for commercial broadcasters who could fill that gap.
I hope the CMA and Ofcom will think again and reject these prominence proposals. Competition works best when regulators referee it, not rig it.