Photo: Getty Images

Sick-note Britain is forgetting how to work

9.1 million people of working age are classed as economically inactive – neither in a job nor looking for one

A welfare system once designed to help people recover now too often rewards withdrawal

Work is not punishment, but the means by which people find independence, pride and purpose

Photo: Getty Images

Share this article

Not long ago, work was part of Britain’s identity. We got up early, joined the morning rush, grumbled about Mondays and did it all again the next day. It wasn’t always enjoyable, but it was expected – part of the rhythm of ordinary life. That rhythm is now breaking down, as more and more Britons fall out of work altogether.

According to the Office for National Statistics, 9.1 million people of working age are classed as economically inactive – neither in a job nor looking for one. That’s just over one in five adults, with around 800,000 more blaming ill health than before the pandemic – a rise of roughly 40% in five years.

The main driver isn’t early retirement, as in many ageing societies, but ill health, above all mental health problems among the young.  A record 2.8m people are now signed off with long-term sickness, and among those aged 18 to 34, mental health-related incapacity claims have risen by 190,000 – up 76% since 2019.

Ministers are finally waking up to the problem. Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, said recently that ‘too many young people have got out of the habit of working’. He’s right – and that simple remark captures a deeper shift. Britain’s problem is not a shortage of jobs, but a slow collapse in the expectation that people will take them.

The cost is staggering. The ‘Keep Britain Working Review’ (the Mayfield Review) estimates that worklessness linked to ill-health drains £85 billion a year from the economy: £10bn from Statutory and Occupational Sick Pay, £47bn from lost output, £21bn from lost productivity and £7bn from litigation and recruitment costs.

It’s easy to see in the data. Personal Independence Payment claims – the main disability benefit for working-age adults – have surged to 3.8m according to the Department for Work and Pensions, up more than half a million in two years. Over a third of new awards are now for anxiety or depression. Meanwhile, almost 3.7m people on Universal Credit – nearly half of all claimants – are officially classed as having no requirement to look for work. A safety net meant to catch people between jobs has become, for too many, a place to stay.

Ten years ago, fewer than 2m adults said sickness kept them out of work. Today, that figure is more than a third higher. Add to that a 9% rise in older workers aged 50 to 64 who have left the workforce since Covid, and it’s little wonder employers complain of chronic staff shortages while millions remain idle and withdraw from the habit of work itself.

The symptoms are not difficult to find. NHS backlogs cause treatable conditions to worsen. Mental health waiting lists stretch into years. The ‘fit-note’ culture sees GPs, often without specialist advice, sign 93% of patients off as ‘not fit for work’, while employers, fearful of liability, rarely challenge it. A welfare system once designed to help people recover and return to employment now too often rewards withdrawal. What began as compassion has hardened into dependency.

So, what can be done? The first step is honesty. Ministers need to admit that this is a national emergency. The Government should, in the Mayfield Review’s words, ‘reset the system’ by tackling the fit-note regime, rewiring incentives and rebuilding the evidence base. Health and employment services must work together so that being signed off no longer means being written off.

Firms also have a role to play. Businesses that invest in occupational health and rehabilitation should be rewarded through tax reliefs. Welfare spending should be redirected towards local recovery and mental health hubs, focused on treatment, structure and training rather than endless paperwork. A system built on recovery would also strengthen the public finances.

Last year’s Budget only made things harder. Higher employers’ National Insurance contributions and a steeper minimum wage have pushed up hiring costs, while the Employment Rights Bill threatens to make the labour market even more difficult.

Britain spent £45bn on health and disability benefits for working-age adults in 2024 – a figure expected to rise to £65bn by 2030. As support unrelated to health, such as unemployment benefits, has been squeezed, more people are pushed into sickness and disability claims. The system flatters the jobless figures but deepens the crisis beneath them.

This isn’t about blaming the sick or the genuinely needy. It’s about confronting a system that traps people and a culture that excuses it. Work is not punishment, but the means by which people find independence, pride and purpose. The decline in work is not just an economic concern but a moral one. When a society stops expecting contribution, it begins to lose confidence in its own future.

Britain doesn’t need to reinvent its work ethic; it needs to rediscover it. Rebuilding that habit, of effort, duty and shared purpose, is the only route to lasting prosperity. Otherwise, we risk becoming a nation that has quietly forgotten how to work.

Share this article

Written by

Damian Pudner is an independent economist specialising in monetary policy and the Director of GBTT.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.