Islamist gangs are raising hell in Britain’s prisons



Just before Christmas, His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) walked out of HMP Swaleside on the Kent coast to issue a rare red flag warning to Ministers. The ‘Urgent Notification’ painted a dystopian picture of an institution no longer in the control of the state, wracked by staff shortages, violence and drugs. The prison was in crisis, with a ‘protracted period of decline’ which meant none of the concerns raised at a previous inspection had been addressed. Indeed, since then, assaults on staff had increased by 122%. The positive rate of drugs testing by officers could be over 50% but no-one knew for sure because so many prisoners were refusing to be tested. Behaviour and consequence had disintegrated.
None of this ought to have been news to senior officials at His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) or their ministerial bosses. But so great is the institutional helplessness and incuriosity of this national law enforcement agency, a high security prison has been allowed to devolve into anarchy in plain sight. One clue in particular to this failure was apparent months before.
Each prison has its own local independent monitoring board (IMB). The IMB report for Swaleside published before national inspectors walked in was close to apocalyptic. ‘Violence is a constant theme and the manufacturing of bladed weapons on site is ominous,’ it said. The inexperience of new staff, bolstered by a huge number of foreign national officers, who were at risk of being sent home again after bungled visa changes, gave prisoners an environment to exploit. Of the 107 assaults on staff, the IMB said that 70% involved prisoners reacting violently to basic instructions from officers. But buried in the detail was something new and worrying. ‘A recurring theme is the perception of widespread violence… As well as unchecked gang control – particularly by religious gangs.’
In answer to a parliamentary question last month, HMPPS said that it did not centrally hold any data on ‘faith or ideology’ related incidents. Yet here we have unusually clear evidence from local monitors that religious gangs are holding sway over legal authority in a jail holding extremely dangerous people. But this phenomenon was reported explicitly to Government in 2022 by its own advisor on terrorism, Jonathan Hall KC. In 2022 he found that Muslim gangs were linked to Islamist extremism and create a ‘fearful environment’ with rising assaults, where privileges like separate food or prayer times reinforce boundaries and an ‘oppositional identity’ among Muslim prisoners. He cited examples including ‘the use of sharia courts and punishment (including flogging)’, ‘assaulting other prisoners for faith-based reasons’ and ‘acting collectively to intimidate staff’. In this context, it is hardly likely that the religious gangs identified by Swaleside’s watchdog are aggressive Methodists.
If HMPPS does not collect or hold information on the nature and extent of religious gangs in prison, it cannot hope to win the battle for power and space that is constantly being waged across prisons holding all of our national security threat. Though I suspect there is also a dose of ‘what we don’t know we can’t be held accountable for’ here too. That risk has teeth. We have been seconds and millimetres away from the murder of prison officers by Islamist extremists on several occasions in the past, as I warned in a government report ten years ago. Yet, instead of decisive action to push back against this malevolent force, officials demonstrate appeasement and ministers cave in to lawfare leaving the front line in an ever more precarious position. Just last week, the High Court inexplicably decided that an Islamist-inspired double murderer who had taken an officer hostage and assaulted others should be awarded compensation for interference with his right to privacy because he was segregated.
In other words, the state is now rewarding people for the inconvenience of not being able to maim or murder officers. Across the prison system, senior officials are more worried about falling foul of crazy interpretations of the European Convention on Human Rights than the fact their establishments holding terrorists are saturated with violence, drugs and wide open to the possibility of drone delivered arms and explosives. Prisons cannot recruit or retain staff because officers are being thrown into the maw of places like Swaleside where asserting lawful authority gets you a free ride to A&E. This sort of corporate failure would not be tolerated in any other public service. We know religion is a thing close to Justice Secretary David Lammy’s heart. He must stop listening to false prophets wearing lanyards who tell him this is as good as it gets.