Healey's do-harm Budget
Getty Images

Healey’s do-harm Budget

The increases in income tax on savings and property income are a direct breach of Labour's manifesto

The 3% increase in bank corporation tax has been limited to a 15-month period – will the Government extend it for a further period?

Changes to self assessment will force the self-employed to pay tax earlier – how is this new burden going to boost growth in every postcode?

Healey's do-harm Budget
Getty Images

Share this article

This was meant to be a do-no-harm Budget. If that was really the aim, it has failed miserably.

It’s a Budget that raises taxes by £7 billion and attacks entrepreneurs, savers and the rental market in particular.

The first point to note is that the increases in income tax on savings and property income are a direct breach of Labour’s manifesto, which promised no income tax hikes. Rachel Reeves even confirmed during the 2024 election campaign that savers were ‘working people’ and thus doubly covered by this promise. ‘There are people who do have savings, who have been able to save up and those are working people as well,’ she told Sky News.

This Budget does cause considerable harm, not just by failing to tackle any of the real problems facing the country, but through its punitive new measures targeting the hardworking and productive

These income tax increases indulge a core aim of Labour think tanks like Torsten Bell’s Resolution Foundation to apply National Insurance (NI) to savings and rental income. But to do it all in one go was seen as too politically difficult, so they are increasing the income tax rate on this income by 2% a year. In a couple of years they’ll have got this supplementary income tax rate up to 8%, matching the standard rate of employee NI. The added advantage for Labour of this approach is that pensioners, while exempt from NI, will have to pay the extra income tax.

But of course the more you tax something, the less you get of it. As the OBR has confirmed this means fewer rental properties and higher rents. It will also mean fewer savings. 

Chancellor John Healey said his Budget was ‘backing the enterprise of British business to unleash innovation and growth in every postcode.’ Why then did he almost eliminate the entrepreneur’s rate of capital gains tax (CGT) by slashing the amount eligible for it to a mere £500,000?

His predecessor, Rachel Reeves, had already increased the rate by 80%. If he really wanted to encourage people to set up new ventures and work their socks off for years to build successful businesses then he would have reversed that tax hike. Instead he introduced a so-called ‘founders’ relief’, which has been hedged about with so many restrictions and qualifications that only a tiny number of people – around 600 – are likely to qualify for it, as opposed to the 61,000 who benefited from the entrepreneur’s rate of CGT in 2024/25.

Healey has attracted some praise by increasing the national minimum wage by less than Labour’s manifesto would suggest. But its level is far too high and is preventing the employment of young people in particular. If you’re in a hole you should stop digging rather than merely digging more slowly. To do no harm there should have been no increase in the national minimum wage whatsoever.

Similarly the attack on banks could have been worse. The 3% increase in bank corporation tax has been supposedly limited to a 15-month period. But who thinks that the government is going to be flush with cash in 15 months’ time and thus won’t extend this bank tax hike for a further period? 

The total tax burden on banks is already 18.5 percentage points higher than on those in New York, in other words a 67% higher combined tax rate. The banking sector is critical to the British economy. Its tax contribution in 2024/25 was £43.3bn, 4.3% of total UK tax receipts. 

Banks play a critical role in the British economy. As of February 2026, the outstanding loans made available by major banks to UK businesses amounted to £582bn, with 34% lent to small and medium-sized enterprises.

British businesses are particularly reliant on banks, which provide 60% of their external financing compared to less than 40% in the US. But British policy since the financial crash has been to attack and constrain the banking sector. The result has been predictable. As Tyler Goodspeed has highlighted ‘whereas real credit to the private business sector in the US recovered to its early 2008 level by mid-2013, in the UK it is still 15% below its level in early 2008.’

Healey’s new tax attack on the banking sector will only make matters worse. With this level of fiscal instability and unpredictability, internationally mobile banks will likely reduce their British presence and domestic banks will further reduce lending and/or increase its price. 

There is no space to analyse the rest of the 98 Budget measures, many of which involved tax increases of one sort or another. It is, however, worth looking at one additional anti-enterprise measure and that is the planned substantial acceleration of tax collection from some 3 million self-assessment taxpayers, which will cause them huge cash-flow difficulties during the transition year of 2029–30.

During that year, taxpayers will need to finish paying liabilities relating to the previous tax year while simultaneously beginning payments under the new arrangements. It is neither fair nor sensible to force the self-employed to finance two different tax years simultaneously, using money they would otherwise have available to operate their businesses, invest or meet personal expenditure. Moreover, even in a normal year there will be significant cash flow problems as people don’t make profits quickly enough that they are available to distribute every quarter.

Stay informed with our free daily briefing.

The true aim of the Making Tax Digital programme – in which the self-employed absurdly have to file five tax returns a year – has been revealed. It’s all about forcing them to pay tax earlier. How this new burden on the self-employed is going to boost growth in every postcode is a little unclear. 

Of course Healey’s Budget could have been worse. It wasn’t as bad as either of Reeves’s first two disastrous Budgets. But since Labour have received such a battering for the economic damage caused by those first Budgets it was never likely that they would try a repeat performance this time. But this Budget does cause considerable harm, not just by failing to tackle any of the real problems facing the country, but through its punitive new measures targeting the hardworking and productive.

Share this article

Written by

Peter Young was formerly Head of Research at the Adam Smith Institute and is an author.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.