Britain cannot plan its way to prosperity

The following is an edited transcript of Lord Wolfson’s keynote speech at the 2026 Margaret Thatcher Conference on Prosperity, organised by the Centre for Policy Studies, in which he argues that replacing Britain’s failed planning system would be the first step towards a freer, faster-growing economy.
My father actually worked for Mrs Thatcher as her Chief of Staff, and I remember her holidaying with us in Cornwall when I was a child. I will share just one memory, because it surprises some. After lunch one day, my mother was horrified to discover the Prime Minister, marigolds on, quietly starting the washing up while the rest of the grown-ups were having coffee. She was a kind and considerate person – as thoughtful towards those serving her as towards her hosts and their children.
Perhaps then all the more remarkable that she also understood something many have forgotten today: that the measures most likely to transform an economy, and a society, are rarely popular at first – and that, in the long run, being right matters more than being liked.
I want to make three points.
The first, is that the solutions to Britain’s growth problems are conceptually simple – few in number and broad in reach; low in cost but powerful in effect.
The second is that although these measures are economically simple, they are politically very difficult.
Thirdly: if we are serious about restoring the UK to growth, then the work must begin now, by those in opposition. Because trying to build a growth plan in government is like trying to fix the wings of an aircraft in flight.
Let me start with what has not worked.
For over a decade we have been told that growth requires industrial strategy. That government should pick sectors and regions, and then make them successful with subsidies, state investments, summits and announcements. Hoping to revive the British economy by spending money the government does not have.
Politically easy. Economically ineffectual. It is like trying to boil the sea, then when that fails concluding that what is needed is a much bigger kettle.
So what will work?
I would choose the following areas, where radical reform could liberate dramatic growth in the UK: Planning, Transport, Energy, Labour and Migration. But the list is not exhaustive.
I will take a couple at length, because I think they illustrate what good reform looks like.
In my view, the UK’s planning system is the single greatest drag on British prosperity. It does not merely prevent us from building enough houses – though it does that spectacularly. It prevents us from building roads, laboratories, reservoirs, power stations, schools, railways and the rest. It succeeds in driving up costs, and restricting competition – a recipe for scarcity and poor quality.
If I were to ask everyone in this room what period of British architecture they most admire, there would be many different answers – Georgian, Gothic, Jacobean, Arts and Crafts – but pretty much all of them would have one thing in common. They would reference a period before 1947: the year Britain introduced comprehensive state planning of development.
Many have tried to reform UK planning – faster decisions, better targets, reallocation of power. All have failed. So I would propose something more radical: that we abolish it. As with some terrible buildings, sometimes you need to tear down and start again.
Because planned economies do not work. They never have. The idea that government, local or national, can decide how many homes we need, where they should be, and what they should look like – is profoundly misconceived. It leaves government with a task far beyond its ability.
Do not panic, I am not mad, and not proposing a free-for-all – far from it. I am suggesting that we replace a planned economy with a regulated one. Let the market decide what is built, where, and how much, BUT subject to clear principles and rules, enforced by government, acting as referee not shadow developer. In short, the way we regulate all other markets.
Three principles would do most of the work.
First, the ‘love thy neighbour’ principle. You may not build that which materially diminishes the value of your neighbour’s property – a narrow, objective test, that could be adjudicated quickly by specialist assessors and courts, rather than negotiated over years with planners and politicians.
Second, a ‘carry your weight’ principle. A new development must leave the public infrastructure – roads, drains, schools – as good as it found it. The cost borne by the development, not the taxpayer.
Third, ‘protect the commons’. A limited amount of land – of real communal value or natural beauty – would be designated and protected by government under something close to the rules we have today.
The effect would be transformative. The supply of developable land would rise by an order of magnitude.
The cost of land would fall. And the money currently sunk into land and planning could be invested into better-quality, lower-cost homes built in the places people most want to live.
Competition drives quality and innovation. Government prevents exploitation. That is the model.
The same logic applies elsewhere.
Take road charging. Charging for roads by the mile does not merely address the long-term decline in fuel duty revenue – it allows us to harness powerful market mechanisms where none exist.
It is extraordinary that we pay the same to use inner city roads at 9:00 in the morning, as we do for a country lane in the middle of the night.
If we charge more at peak times on our busiest roads, people will plan more carefully – reducing travel cost for those who want to save, reducing congestion for those who value speed. This type of pricing democratised air travel, and will transform our roads.
More than that: revenue will be attached to the road that generates it. So road improvements create a clear return for the Treasury. That means capital can flow to where it is most valuable, not where it is most politically visible. And, of course, private capital can invest in public infrastructure – taking pressure off the taxpayer.
Finally, we can address a universal bugbear. All those companies who close a lane, or dig up a road, can pay for their disruption. Suddenly the economics of roadworks look very different. Those closed lanes you see in rush hour, with no workmen visible, I suspect they will disappear rather quickly.
The pattern repeats across the economy.
Energy liberalisation – permitting North Sea development, onshore gas, accelerated nuclear – allows private capital to do what we currently pay Qatar to do for us.
Labour market deregulation means repealing the most damaging parts of the Employment Rights Act – because if you attach liability to the provision of jobs, you will get fewer jobs.
And a priced work visa system would replace the judgment of Home Office bureaucrats with more efficient and discerning market forces.
You will notice these measures have something in common.
None of them is an exercise in cleverness on the part of government. None require ministers to pick winners, direct investment, or outthink the market. They share three other important characteristics:
First, they change the rules of the game rather than trying to play it. They restore government to its proper role: that of referee. Government is good at setting rules. It is, almost without exception, bad at making commercial decisions.
Second, they permit growth rather than compel it. They are about government taking its foot off the brake, not pressing the accelerator.
Third, they rest on a particular view of the British people. They assume that we are enterprising, hardworking, intelligent and motivated. That whilst we need to be prevented from harming each other, we do not need to be forced to be productive, innovative and enterprising.
This is not a claim that people are perfect, or that markets are infallible. The rules matter. Enforcing them is serious work and markets without regulation are rarely, if ever, truly free.
But within a proper framework of law, a free people can achieve far more than could ever be imagined by any government. So government should focus on just that: creating the right framework.
Which brings me to my second argument. If these reforms are so economically straightforward, why has none of them been done?
The conventional answer is vested interests and fear of change, with a nasty dose of bureaucratic inertia thrown on top. All true. But I think there is something deeper.
Every one of these ideas will generate opposition before it produces benefit. Every one requires a politician to stand up and say something the public may not want to hear, and to keep saying it until they do.
This is the Thatcher lesson. Good economic policy requires courage – the willingness to be unpopular for a period in pursuit of being right in the end. It requires persuasion – the patient, repeated, public-facing work of bringing the country with you. It requires ambition – the conviction that office is only worth winning if you use it well. And it requires risk – the conscious decision that it is preferable to lose on the right platform than to win on the wrong one.
I realise this is a brave choice that I am asking someone else to make. But I do not believe that trusting in the good sense of the British public is really that risky.
Everything I see of the world – the contact I have with my colleagues, customers and friends – suggests that the British public is far more sensible, more thoughtful and more tolerant than our pollster generation gives them credit for.
The case for economic reform has not been lost in front of the British people. It has not been made to them. There is a difference. Trust the British people with a serious argument, made seriously and over time, and they will surprise their would-be managers. They always have.
Which brings me to my third argument, and to my conclusion.
It seems to be a universal truth that a government’s best work is done in opposition – when it has the time to think and prepare.
Government is a battlefield. Ministers must fit complex legislation into a narrow parliamentary timetable, avoid the quagmire of judicial review, and do so under the constant scrutiny of a 24-hour news cycle.
So if the next administration is to achieve anything, it must start preparing now. A new government must arrive with clear priorities, well-drafted bills and carefully selected ministers. It must also make unequivocal manifesto commitments, laying the foundations for parliamentary discipline, binding its own backbenches and heading off obstruction in the Lords.
The first Thatcher government hit the ground running because it had been running for years – here at the CPS, at the IEA, in seminars, pamphlets and patient argument. The intellectual groundwork was laid before office, not after. The next government will only have that luxury if that work begins now.
It feels as though this Government may have already lost the next election. But that is not the point: the critical question is not whether they will be replaced. It is whether they will be replaced with something much better.
And that will be down to the thinking and work done by those now in opposition. Our country’s future rests in their hands. If they prepare well, Britain can shake off the economic lethargy of the last decade and return to the prosperity its people so richly deserve.