Banking competition is a UK success story



Your bank account tells a bigger story about you than almost anything else you own. What you earn, what you spend, whether you settle up on time. For most of the history of British banking only one firm could read that story and act on it, and that was the bank that held your account. The money was yours. The information about it was theirs.
Open banking changed that, and it is one of the quieter UK economic successes of the last decade.
Put simply, open banking lets you tell your bank to share your account information with another firm you trust, or to let that firm make a payment from your account on your behalf.
There is also a competitive opening for the UK, because some of our competitors are stuck. The European Union is still arguing over its own open finance rules, and America’s version has been held up in the courts
Nothing happens without your say-so. You choose who sees what, and you can switch it off at any time. The other firm has to be approved by the Financial Conduct Authority, and it never sees your password. The largest banks were made to build a common, secure route into their systems so that all this could happen safely.
You may already use it without realising. If you have paid a tax bill to HMRC straight from your banking app, or used an app that shows accounts from several different banks on one screen, that is open banking at work.
There are several advantages to open banking.
For one, it makes banks compete harder. For years the big banks had, some would say, too little incentive to fight for customers. In 2016 the competition watchdog found that the four largest banks held over 70% of personal current accounts and around 80% of business accounts. Once newer firms can see, with your permission, how you actually use your money, they can offer you a better deal, and bigger players have to respond.
Open banking also makes paying cheaper and quicker. Money sent straight from one bank account to another arrives in seconds and avoids card fees, which shops end up passing on to their customers. For poorer people this is especially important.
It also helps people borrow on fairer terms. A lender who can see a year of your real income and spending can say yes to a self-employed plumber or a young business that a crude credit score might turn away.
It also saves small firms time. Their accounting software can pull in bank transactions automatically, instead of someone typing them in at the kitchen table at the end of the week.
Take-up has been significant. More than 40 million open banking payments were made in May alone, and in June the total passed 1 billion since the launch. Analysis by EY estimates that open banking has already delivered over £8bn of benefit to the UK economy, and could be worth up to £43bn a year once it is widely used.
And all of this kicked off on the Conservative Party’s watch. In 2017 the nine largest banks were required to open their systems to approved rivals using a common standard, and customers gained a legal right to share their data with them. The UK model has since been used as a blueprint by more than 60 other countries.
Conservative governments then set out to go further. The aim was to take the same idea beyond current accounts to savings, pensions, mortgages and insurance, known as ‘open finance’, and we prepared the legal powers to make that possible. Labour have since passed those powers into law, and the industry and regulators have launched a new way to pay regular bills directly from your bank account. So there has been some progress.
But that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t or couldn’t move faster. The Treasury has promised to bring in the regulations that open banking needs for its next stage, including extending those flexible regular payments to online shopping and subscriptions, by the end of this year. To date it has not done so. Meanwhile the regulator does not expect full open finance schemes to launch until possibly as late as 2030.
There is also a competitive opening for the UK, because some of our competitors are stuck. The European Union is still arguing over its own open finance rules, and America’s version has been held up in the courts.
On open finance, though, one or two countries have moved ahead of us. Brazil and India already let people share data on savings, investments and insurance, reaching hundreds of millions of people.
So what now? The Treasury should be pressed on four things. First, bring in the promised regulations before Christmas. Second, make permanent the arrangements that let banks earn a fair fee for the access they provide, so they have a reason to improve the service rather than just tolerate it. Third, bring the start of open finance forward to 2027, perhaps beginning with lending to small businesses. Fourth, lead by example so that every payment to central and local government, from council tax to parking fines, can be paid as easily as a tax bill to HMRC, straight from a bank account.
Perhaps the best news of all is that none of this needs new government spending. But it does need a Chancellor who understands that the cheapest growth policy is often to stop slowing down good ideas that are already in motion.
John Healey has been in the job for long enough now to have his feet under the desk. He has inherited a great UK invention. He must not be the Chancellor who lets it stall.