Burnham's EU reset figures have already unravelled
JUSTIN TALLIS / AFP via Getty Images

Burnham’s EU reset figures have already unravelled

The Government’s own statisticians have completely contradicted the Prime Minister

Output per hour is now 8.8% above its 2019 level, not 3.4%

In recent years Britain’s productivity growth has been second in the G7, behind only the United States

Burnham's EU reset figures have already unravelled
JUSTIN TALLIS / AFP via Getty Images

Share this article

We’ve all had that feeling. You wake up after a boozy dinner and worry that you’ve said something stupid that will embarrass you. Well, on Monday evening, the man who is inexplicably Prime Minister told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in the City of London that, ‘to be frank, we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years’ from Brexit. The following morning, the Government’s own statisticians completely contradicted him.

This is particularly sweet timing this week, because tomorrow will see a ‘summit’ in Brussels, where Andy Burnham is hoping to pull us closer to the EU again. His case rests on the idea that leaving made us poorer and less productive. ‘The OBR says Brexit has meant a 4% hit to the British economy,’ he told the City, before adding that others put it at ‘up to 8% of GDP’. 

But the ONS has improved the way it counts the hours we work, having overstated them for years. Under the new ‘component approach’, productivity growth between 2009 and 2019 was 1.3% a year, nearly double the 0.7% we had been told. Output per hour is now 8.8% above its 2019 level, not 3.4%. And in the 10 years to 2007, to 2017 and to 2025, Britain’s productivity growth was second in the G7, behind only the United States.

Even someone as insouciantly ignorant as Burnham must realise, in his heart, that he’s talking complete balls on the EU, even before the ONS blew his stats out of the water

Simon French, the impressive chief economist at Panmure Liberum, has described this revision of British productivity post the referendum as showing Britain ‘accelerating away’ from comparable EU economies, with the gap over the average of Germany, France and Italy widening from 12% in 2016 to 22% in 2025. The independent economist Julian Jessop put it more bluntly: ‘there is no sign of a Brexit effect in these charts’.

The City itself, for its part, has already said no. TheCityUK, which speaks for financial services, said in July that automatic dynamic alignment with EU rules ‘is not appropriate’ for the industry, and Burnham’s own officials have told Brussels that financial services are a red line. Researchers at the investment bank Morgan Stanley say the promised investment boost ‘cannot be viewed with any conviction’. So, what’s good enough for the bankers is apparently not good enough for our farmers and factories. Brexit for the Square Mile, Brussels for the shires. Imagine hearing that 10 years ago…

I’m not convinced, however, of the Tory tactic to refuse to get into the debate. It’s clear that Burnham is pushing it as an electoral issue, rather than anything based remotely in what might be considered reality. Helpfully, I’m not the only person who thinks this. Stay Out, the new campaign run by Boris Johnson’s former deputy Brexit negotiator Oliver Lewis and backed by much of the old Vote Leave team, have done the sums. 

They say that Rejoin would cost about £39 billion a year gross, or £750m a week, against just £19.1bn in 2016. The EU budget is heading for roughly €2 trillion, and the EU’s former Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier has said that a new British rebate would be ‘off the table’. 

The Prosperity Institute’s Fred de Fossard is another unmissable voice in how mendacious this Government has become. He highlights the extent of Labour’s lies, with only one logical end to their ‘reset’ – making rejoining a fait accompli, to use a phrase I’m sure the EU loves.

Stay informed with our free daily briefing.

None of this means Britain should turn its back on Europe. By all means let us build deeper defence ties through NATO, where our armed forces, our intelligence services and our nuclear deterrent are worth more to our neighbours than anything they can sell us. That is in our interests and in theirs. It’s also a much better card to play to achieve market access, tariff reductions, or that holy grail of the stalwart Remain supporter, shorter airport arrival queues.

Even someone as insouciantly ignorant as Burnham must realise, in his heart, that he’s talking complete balls on the EU, even before the ONS blew his stats out of the water. But that won’t stop him repeating the lies, nor stop voters, casting around for something to blame, from believing them. So it’s time to rejoin the fight for our sovereignty once again.

Share this article

Written by

James Price is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute and a CPS research fellow

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.