Subsidised jobs are not real, whatever Milburn says



On Sunday, the Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden proposed a solution to Britain’s youth worklessness: a statute. Speaking on the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Mr McFadden agreed with Alan Milburn’s diagnosis that the support available to young people is ‘vague’ and needs ‘legislative underpinning’ to guarantee job placements for under-25s. Mr Milburn’s review is due on Tuesday and will make the case in full.
With some 981,000 (or one in eight) young people aged 16 to 24 not in education, employment or training, the instinct is understandable. In the three months to August, youth unemployment stood at 15.6% – up from 14.6% in the same period last year, and more than three times the national average of 4.7%.
Having priced young people out, the Government now dangles schemes at them
But what young people lack isn’t schemes and laws; its employers willing and able to take a chance on them. This lack of such opportunities is almost entirely of Whitehall’s making.
Consider the measures the Starmer government took to change the remit of the Low Pay Commission. Following its election victory, it enacted its manifesto promise to guarantee a so-called ‘genuine living wage’ for working people by narrowing the gap between the rate for 18- to 20-year-olds and the National Living Wage. This was an early step towards a single adult rate, increasing the minimum wage 16.3% from £8.60 to £10 in April 2025, and then a further 8.5% to £10.85 – a 26.2% rise in just two years, around three times faster than the growth in average regular pay over the same period. Furthermore, April 2025 saw Rachel Reeves’s increase of employer National Insurance contributions from 13.8% to 15% and the lowering of the qualifying threshold from £9,100 to £5,000. On top of this, changes in the Employment Rights Act which reduced the qualifying period for unfair dismissal claims from two years to six months, while giving zero-hour workers a right to guaranteed hours made employing young people a riskier prospect. These changes bite the part-time, low-paid worker the hardest.
As predicted, employers did what classic economics textbooks say they will: in the year to August, payrolled employment fell by 111,000 and vacancies – at 691,000 – fell to their lowest since 2014. While in the third quarter of this year the economy did grow by 0.7%, it was boosted largely by growth in consultancy and software – areas that can function without hiring much. Added to this, the Bank of England raising interest rates to 4%, making borrowing and investment more expensive, does not suggest a revival of hiring is likely any time soon.
Having priced young people out, the Government now dangles schemes at them. The overarching project is the £820 million Youth Guarantee scheme. This incorporates the Jobs Guarantee scheme, that is intended to help up to 90,000 young people by March 2029 by offering them six-month subsidised part-time minimum wage jobs; beneficiaries must have been looking for work for 18 months, dropping to 12 months from 2027.
According to Milburn, earlier schemes such as Kickstart have underdelivered because they are temporary. On this assumption, the solution is obvious: make it permanent and write it into law to ensure it delivers as expected. But the Jobs Guarantee inherently suffers from the same problem: subsidised placements only last as long as the subsidy is in place. Real jobs resulting from that would only exist depending on the cost on employers to take on subsidised staff under their payroll.
To illustrate, consider another temporary subsidy: the legal duty on councils to accommodate homeless people. While this duty has filled temporary housing, it has not led to more house building. Mr McFadden says that a legal guarantee as he proposes must be thought out carefully, but regardless of how careful it would be, it will only generate busywork and bureaucracy, not the much-needed full-time jobs young people want and deserve. Helen Whately is right to expose the absurdity of taxing employers to ‘subsidise things that look like jobs’.
To give Alan Milburn some credit, in his own Kuenssberg interview, he called for the Government to reconsider its position on abolishing the youth minimum wage as it has imposed a lot of costs on firms. He also called for a doubling of the National Insurance threshold to £10,000 for 21- to 24-year-olds over five years. This agrees with critics’ diagnoses but postpones the cure. Why should it take five years to unwind a tax rise that was raised in a single April?
There is a better course of action that would be more helpful to young people. Reverse the employer National Insurance rise in full and do so now. Freeze the minimum wage, as I proposed in a recent co-authored report for the Prosperity Institute. Repeal the changes to the qualifying period in the Employment Rights Act.
Employers only employ if they can justify that the benefits outweigh the cost. Parliament cannot legislate jobs into existence.