The NHS tells Labour to leave zero-hour contracts alone
Getty Images

The NHS tells Labour to leave zero-hour contracts alone

Local authorities warn Andy Burnham that legislating zero-hour contracts would be expensive and cumbersome

Labour see zero-hour contracts as oppressive rather than offering flexibility and choice

The NHS Alliance predicts that heavy regulation could cost the health service £900 million and require 1,500 new employees

The NHS tells Labour to leave zero-hour contracts alone
Getty Images

Share this article

For some years now, any Labour politician has been able to generate morale-sustaining applause from an audience by railing against ‘exploitative zero-hours contracts’. They are the perfect image of bosses weaponising their power over employees, putting workers in shackles with no guarantee of work, an arrangement wholly for the convenience of the plutocracy.

So powerful has this image become that it was an inevitable target of the Employment Rights Act 2025, the legislation that sprang from Angela Rayner’s cherished green paper ‘Labour’s New Deal for Working People’. This, Labour pledged, would be written into law within 100 days of Sir Keir Starmer taking office; actually, it took 533 days.

The Prime Minister could cling on to legislation that will cost the public sector money and potentially damage front-line services, but plays well as a slogan with a left-wing audience

It was enshrined in section 1(1) of the act, under the rubric ‘Zero hours workers, etc.’, and provided that ‘An employer must make a guaranteed hours offer to a worker’.

Neil Kinnock, the man who did more than perhaps any other to save the Labour Party from irrelevance in the 1980s, knows the dangers of simple slogans all too well. It was his harsh but necessary message to Militant at the 1985 annual party conference in Bournemouth.

You start with far-fetched resolutions. They are then pickled into a rigid dogma, a code, and you go through the years sticking to that, outdated, misplaced, irrelevant to the real needs.

Now, Andy Burnham’s government is being warned that legislation on zero-hours contracts is an administrative burden, cumbersome and liable to cost money in the public sector. These warnings are coming not from bastions of heartless, exploitative, Gradgrindian capitalism like the CBI, the IEA, the Institute of Directors or even the Centre for Policy Studies. Alarmingly and befuddling for Burnham and his nostalgic-for-the-1970s, folkloric leftist instincts, the admonitions represent incoming fire from the NHS, the fire service and local authorities. These are unfamiliar antagonists.

The argument they are advancing is an obvious and simple one: the NHS, the fire brigades and other service providers like care home workers require flexibility to respond to changing circumstances, and cannot predict exactly what their workforce needs will be. But the act requires that employees must have a guaranteed number of hours of work, reasonable notice of changes to shifts and compensatory payment for shifts which are cancelled or moved.

The NHS Alliance has predicted that a shift to this more heavily regulated model could cost the health service £900 million and require 1,500 new employees in administration and management. A spokesman for the fire service expressed the point more drolly: ‘emergencies are not predictable and their numbers are not consistent across the year’.

The Government’s response has been a typical cocktail of sanctimoniousness, shallow thinking, that pickled rigid dogma that Kinnock saw in Militant in the 1980s. Starmer’s régime could only see zero-hour contracts as workers’ shackles, never as a means to maximise flexibility and choice. They had to be wrong, morally wrong, on principle and therefore swept away, even if some employees protested; those protesting had to be pawns, or collaborators, or victims of Stockholm syndrome.

The demonisation of zero-hours contracts was easier when they imposed exclusivity on the employee: your boss could by the terms of your contract prevent you from working for anyone else, in return for which they had no obligations to you. But the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment 2015, a product of the coalition, declared exclusivity clauses legally unenforceable – too many people are trying to slay a dragon that was hunted to extinction years ago.

How has the Burnham government responded to this critique? Not with a bang but with a simper.

We are committed to tackling the one-sided flexibility that can result from zero-hours and similar contracts, when workers bear all the financial risk of uncertain hours, shifts and earnings… We’re grateful for the many responses we received to our consultation.

But there is no ‘one-sided flexibility’. It’s been relegated to the status of urban myth. This means the Government’s true nature will soon be revealed: it would be easy for Burnham to explain that he inherited the legislation, that he has listened to ‘real people’ and to trade unions since taking over, and he accepts that this provision of guaranteed work may not be adaptable to every part of the economy. He could do what he ought to do as a reasonable, pragmatic leader interested in outcomes.

Stay informed with our free daily briefing.

Or the Prime Minister could cling on to legislation that will cost the public sector money and potentially damage front-line services, but plays well as a slogan with a left-wing audience.

The choice Andy Burnham makes will reveal a huge amount about the kind of Prime Minister he is going to be. Does he want to be effective or loved?

Share this article

Written by

Eliot Wilson is Senior Fellow for National Security at the Coalition for Global Prosperity.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.