Getty Images

Why Britain’s lost generation can’t get ahead

Over half a million 18–24-year-olds are unemployed and actively seeking work in England

Britain's lost generation did what they were told – and got little in return

Our political class courted the votes of older generations by neglecting the young

Getty Images

Share this article

The rules of growing up in modern Britain appeared to be simple for decades: if you work hard at school, go to university and graduate with a degree, you will come out with a well-paid job that sets you up for life.

The argument seemed straightforward: since graduates earned considerably more than non-graduates, the way to improve social mobility and average income was to encourage more people to go to university. So strong was society’s emphasis on this pathway that, in 1999, the Government set a target for half of all young adults to pursue higher education ‘in the next century’.

A quarter of a century on, the promise that attending university definitively leads to a better life looks increasingly threadbare. Graduates are not emerging into a labour market with rising demand for their skills. Instead, the jobs they were told there would be are now declining year-on-year, making each position more competitive: according to recent data, there are around 140 applicants for every graduate role. Indeed, the job market is now so tough for young people that many can only find employment where having a degree is not a requirement, nor even clearly beneficial to their performance in it.

For some, it’s even worse. Data released last week indicates that over half a million 18-24-year-olds are unemployed and actively seeking work in England. In some areas of the country, one in five of this generation want a job, but cannot find one. In fact, there are more young, unemployed people searching for work in England right now than there are people living in Iceland.

What is more, many are saddled with debts that will last their entire working lives. Student loans were presented as a rational trade off: higher earnings over the long-term in exchange for going into debt early in life. While graduates do still earn more than non-graduates on average, many find that much of the extra earnings are removed by interest-laden repayments that effectively function as a graduate tax.

Those on Plan 2 loans are particularly struggling. The interest on this cohort’s debt is based upon the retail prices index plus three percentage points, which increases in lock-step with salaries; this means despite repaying several hundreds of pounds each month, many will see their total debt continue to grow. In fact, according to some estimates, graduates need a salary of around £66,000 before they can start reducing their debts – roughly £30,000 more than the average graduate salary.

Concurrently, they are facing wider social and economic problems. Housing is at its most unaffordable in decades, and most are forced to pay astronomical rents to live in poor conditions. Energy prices are amongst the highest in the world, and young workers are shouldering the highest tax burden in three-quarters of a century to fund services disproportionately used by older generations, all while struggling to build any wealth themselves.

The consequences go beyond individual bank accounts. Geographic mobility is in long-term decline because young people cannot often afford to move where opportunities exist, and family formation has been delayed by the instability that young people now live with.

We are witnessing the creation of a lost generation. Not lost to war or plague, but to a series of deliberate policy choices that have dismantled the social and economic rulebook our young people were taught to play by.

In our political class’s attempts to court the votes of older generations, they chose to neglect our young people. They sacrificed affordable house prices so existing homeowners could see their assets increase in value, and reinforced a labyrinth of planning regulations, even as housebuilding rapidly declined. 

Meanwhile, the university expansion experiment proceeded without regard for the labour market. The binary choice between university and an unwarranted stigma of failure became so entrenched that degrees in subjects with limited economic value proliferated, despite no obvious growing demand, while apprenticeships in skilled trades declined, even though it was clear that a recruitment crisis was developing.

These were conscious decisions: they can be changed. Our politicians can decide to prioritise the lost generation, to make it easier to build and scale businesses here, and to ease the regulatory burden on employers so they can provide the jobs for first time employees. Through changes in policy, they can give more of our young people the opportunity to work, to buy their first home and to rebuild trust with an age group that has thus far been failed by our political class.

Britain’s lost generation deserve more than being told they are lazy and unemployable, or to be more patient. They did what they were told. They worked hard at school. They went to university and got a degree. But when they graduated, many found the prize they were promised for years of effort was largely empty.

The longer this chasm between promise and reality remains, the clearer it becomes that the failure lies not with a generation, but with those who govern it. Our politicians must choose to govern differently. They must now act by building an economy that lets people own a home and build a family, and defeating the army of consultants, lawyers and lobbyists who have held young people back. Through this radical action, Britain’s lost generation can still be saved. The test facing our political class is whether they are willing to do it.

Share this article

Written by

Dr Lawrence Newport is the Director and co-founder of Looking for Growth, a political movement to end decline and save Britain.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.