Photo: Getty Images

From Left to Right, we all know our tax system has to change

All the conversation in Westminster is about raising taxes, not fixing taxes

We can get more growth by make the tax system simpler, fairer and more efficient

A new report seeks to bridge the political divide on tax

Photo: Getty Images

Share this article

It’s no secret that the UK tax system is a mess. In fact, it’s so bad, that if you locked a bunch of left-wing and right-wing think tankers in a room, they could largely agree on what needed to change – even though they’d agree on precious little else.

That’s why the Centre for the Analysis of Taxation (CenTax), the Centre for Policy Studies (CapX’s parent organisation, where I work), the Adam Smith Institute, Bright Blue, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF), Labour Together, the New Economics Foundation and the IPPR have co-authored a document suggesting a set of pro-growth tax reforms. 

Of course, we all disagree over our visions for the optimal tax system, and we especially disagree over the amount of tax that should be raised. The CPS, for example, would like to see much lower taxes and a smaller state. Others would like to see higher taxes and a larger state. But we all agree that the current tax system raises money in a damaging way. 

The result is a package of addressing seven areas for reform, and outlining some broad principles for change.

The first package is on property tax. Everyone agrees that it is absurd we base council tax rates on 1991 house values, and that stamp duty does enormous economic damage by depressing the housing market and making it harder to buy. So pretty much everyone could get behind a deal that saw stamp duty abolished and council tax based on current house values as a quid pro quo. 

Secondly, most people are familiar with the absurd exemptions with the VAT system: for example, how the size of a marshmallow determines whether it is charged 0% or 20% VAT. By widening the VAT base, we can lower the overall rate of VAT – though we accept politicians might be wary given the ‘pasty tax’ fiasco.

The third package addresses high marginal tax rates and knife-edge benefit withdrawals. For example, parents of young children lose childcare subsidies as soon as either parent earns £100,000. Addressing these high marginal rates improves incentives to work more and take higher paying jobs. 

Fourth, we could all agree that it doesn’t really make much sense to have both National Insurance and income tax as separate taxes, when they are both very similar taxes on work – not least because the amount someone pays in National Insurance bears no relation to how much they actually get out of the system. These should be merged. 

The fifth package would allow for deductions for mortgage interest for landlords, helping to increase the supply of rental properties in the UK. 

The sixth package would introduce an investment allowance for Capital Gains Tax. This would ensure that people would only pay for real (not inflationary) gains. As part of this we have also suggested that people pay tax only on the gains they make in the UK. This is admittedly one of the areas where the signatories did disagree strongly on the detail, given the damage ‘exit taxes’ have done in countries like Norway. Certainly, we at the CPS would want to make sure any such policy was not applied retrospectively to past gains, and was designed to minimise the impact on investment. 

Finally, we agreed on the need to extend full expensing to make all capital expenditure fully deductible at the point of purchase. Increasing capital investment through tax reform by businesses would help to improve productivity. 

There’s plenty in all this that other people may agree with, or disagree with – certainly, we all had to make some compromises during the process. But the key theme that we could all agree on was simplification. Simplifying the tax system means businesses and HMRC spend less time and cost dealing with complex rules. It also means people and businesses are making decisions based on economic, not tax, considerations. It means remove or reducing the distortions that stop people doing the right thing for their family, community or business. 

It’s rare that you can get a left-right consensus on anything these days, but the tax system is so broken that opportunities for reform are plentiful. Which is a pretty depressing thing to say.

Share this article

Written by

Daniel Herring
Daniel Herring is Head of Economic & Fiscal Policy at the Centre for Policy Studies.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.