Man smiling during a political discussion at a conference.
A man smiling during a political discussion at a conference, surrounded by other attendees.

The real reason Democratic Socialists are winning

80% of the Democratic Socialists of America's members have a bachelor’s degree, compared to 37.5% nationwide

The average American doesn’t want to defund the police but they do want lower rent and more affordable healthcare

The socialists may have the wrong answers, but the questions they're asking are real

Man smiling during a political discussion at a conference.
A man smiling during a political discussion at a conference, surrounded by other attendees.

Share this article

‘A Waiter in Paris’ is the story of a young Englishman who graduated from a good university in London with a humanities degree, trained and educated for a world that no longer exists. ‘All while I applied for other, more “prestigious” jobs. Jobs that didn’t appear to exist anymore.’ That’s how Edward Chisholm puts it in the book. The story of Chisholm isn’t limited to himself; it is also shaping a political force on the other side of the Atlantic.

The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) are gaining popularity. From Abdul El-Sayed’s victory in Michigan’s primary – although he is not an official member, his views are mostly identical to those of the DSA, from his views on Israel to his support for abolishing ICE – to Zohran Mamdani, who is now the mayor of New York, and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, also known simply as AOC, who, according to Polymarket odds, is now the frontrunner to become the 2028 Democratic presidential nominee.

The DSA is part of a larger trend of young people who graduated from top universities, mostly with humanities degrees, who see that the job market isn’t as friendly as their university years suggested it would be

The Democratic Socialists of America have an interesting membership. Among its members, 80% have completed university with at least a bachelor’s degree, which is a huge difference compared with roughly 37.5% nationwide. But when we look at their wages, things get more interesting: about 45% of adult members report household incomes below $60,000 per year. The DSA is part of a larger trend of young people who graduated from top universities, mostly with humanities degrees, who see that the job market isn’t as friendly as their university years suggested it would be.

This goes back to economics. The overreach of the state in higher education, as well as the subsidising and incentivising of people to study degrees that don’t pay well in the job market, has created a middle class in urban areas that feels it isn’t getting what it deserves from society. Their mate who studied a STEM degree or economics now has a six-figure pay cheque and is starting a family. While they have found out that a career in student activism isn’t going to prepare them for the job market. And these educated middle class young people have, historically, been among those most attracted to ideas of socialism.

Let’s go back to May 1968 in Paris, where pictures of Lenin and Mao were all over universities and caused Charles de Gaulle to leave the country for a while for fear of revolution. One man observed it well, and it changed the course of his thinking. Roger Scruton, seeing the would-be revolutionaries, described them as ‘an unruly mob of self-indulgent middle-class hooligans.’ But why do the young and educated tend to like socialism?

The American philosopher Robert Nozick provides an answer. He believed that this class of intellectuals felt that, in a capitalist society, they weren’t in the positions of power and influence they deserved. People who were less educated than them, and hadn’t read the theory they had, earned vastly more than them. ‘This isn’t fair!’ So, in the socialist utopia in their minds, they would occupy the highest social status, managing society. Historically, however, this seems to have been one of their biggest misconceptions, because there is no guarantee that, in their socialist utopia, they wouldn’t end up in a gulag rather than in the big mansions for a few state-approved ‘engineers of human souls’.

But the feeling is real. They have been promised a world that doesn’t exist. It’s harder to get on the housing ladder, and with cuts to subsidies for humanities courses, it’s harder for them to find a career in academia. That’s the reason for the DSA’s wider appeal. As Gerard Baker wrote for the Wall Street Journal, the socialists may have the wrong answers, but ‘the questions are real’. And to their credit, the DSA have chosen a new strategy that has a higher chance of appealing to centrist voters.

AOC, in one of her latest interviews, confessed, ‘Woke 1 was crazy.’ This is a vibe shift. Although it’s hard to believe that DSA members have changed their beliefs, they have learned that the average American celebrating Thanksgiving with their family doesn’t believe we should cancel Thanksgiving, as Wisconsin State Representative Francesca Hong suggested. The Mamdani campaign focused on the ‘cost of living’. Abdul El-Sayed’s campaign has focused on proposals for reducing the cost of healthcare and housing. And the right needs to recognise this. One of the reasons for Trump’s second victory was that he was seen as a force for common sense, as Scott Jennings put it in his book, ‘A Revolution of Common Sense’.

Stay informed with 
our free daily briefing.

The average American doesn’t want to defund the police, cancel Thanksgiving, abolish prisons or get rid of the Senate. But they do want lower rent, more affordable healthcare and, as recent polls show, less American involvement in foreign wars. The DSA have understood this, but the Right hasn’t. Trump and his team have lately been campaigning against them by labelling them communists. Although many of them are, they are also campaigning on reasonable concerns about economic matters. And we may once again find Clinton’s famous motto to be right in US politics: ‘It’s the economy, stupid.’

Share this article

Written by

Mani Basharzad is a Junior Research Associate at the Institute of Economic Affairs and an economic journalist.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.