Slogans won’t get Britain building again


If we judge governments by rhetoric alone, then this Labour Government is, by a country mile, the most pro-development in history.
At the Labour Party Conference a few weeks ago, Housing Secretary Steve Reed proudly wore a hat bearing the slogan: ‘Build Baby Build’. In fact, the most common sight at the conference was Reed signing hats for Labour-supporting Yimbys.
The Chancellor has taken a similarly strong line. In response to a question about whether the Government’s planning reforms were sufficient to get rid of 350,000-page planning applications, she said: ‘I’m afraid that, as a country, we have cared more about the bats than we have about the commuter times for people in Leeds and West Yorkshire. We have to change that. I care more about a young family getting on the housing ladder than I do about protecting some snails.’
With talk like this, you’d think Yimbys like me would be punching the air and celebrating. But unfortunately, I’m far from convinced.
The problem is that the Government is investing a huge amount of political capital in making the case for radical reform of planning and environmental protections, while the actual measures fail miserably to fix any of the problems they’ve identified. They are, in the words of The Economist’s Duncan Robinson, taking an ‘all pain, no gain’ approach.
Clearly, homes for young people should come ahead of snails. But the Government’s planning reforms don’t reflect this. Instead, it strives to deliver a ‘win-win’ where snails can be protected while homes are built.
A key plank of the Planning Bill sought to protect nature more efficiently, by cutting red tape and taking a strategic approach. Given the insanity of nuclear fish discos, £216 million bat tunnels, and 350,000-page planning applications, that shouldn’t be a controversial premise.
Yet the rhetoric on bats, newts and snails has provoked vehement opposition from green NGOs like the RSPB and Friends of the Earth. Their pushback was so strong that the Government eventually amended the Bill to make it much harder to use the strategic approach.
While the Planning Bill may not go far enough, the Government has done some good.
They’ve brought back housing targets, raised them in the least affordable places, and councils will face serious consequences for missing them. The effective ban on onshore wind in England has been lifted. And the Government has tried to limit the number of consultations big infrastructure projects like Sizewell C have to run just to avoid being sued.
But let’s be clear, what’s been put forward so far is insufficient to solve the problems that Reed, Reeves and Starmer have correctly identified.
Housebuilding has collapsed. Just 231,000 homes were built last year in England. Build at that rate for another four years and Labour will fall 514,506 homes short of their 1.5m target. But it’s not just housebuilding that has collapsed. Data released last week revealed that, across the board, construction activity has fallen off a cliff. This should be a wake-up call for the Prime Minister and his Cabinet.Or take the Lower Thames Crossing’s £300m, 360,000-page planning application. There is no better symbol of Britain’s planning dysfunction. Yet is there any better evidence that the reforms put forward by the Government are not sufficient than the news that Heathrow estimates their planning application will cost £820m to prepare. Almost £1bn to get permission from the Government to build something that the Government themselves are convinced is vital to boosting economic growth.
So what do they need to do?
First, there’s the need for densification of our most productive cities. The long-delayed Brownfield Passport must be delivered and must have real teeth.
Second, we desperately need to reform the system of environmental protection. Any benefit of the Planning and Infrastructure Bill will be limited without reform of the Habitats Regulations, which are the underlying cause of 80,000-page environmental impact assessments and expensive mitigations like bat tunnels.
Third, the Building Safety Regulator (BSR), which was conceived in good faith, needs reform – otherwise it is unlikely London will ever get building again. The BSR alone is blocking thousands of homes in the capital, including 1,210 completed homes stuck empty because the regulator couldn’t sign them off.
The truth is that while the Planning Bill contains many worthwhile reforms, it is unlikely they will be sufficient to deliver the quick streamlined planning system every Yimby hoped it would.
In the 16 months since the Bill was first announced in the King’s Speech, the British economy has sunk deeper into crisis, and Starmer’s dream of boosting growth by making it quicker and easier to build is further out of reach.
We need a planning system that actually supports growth, backs builders not blockers, and makes it possible to get spades in the ground quickly. Sadly, even after the Planning Bill becomes law, we will still be a long way from achieving that.