LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 24: Prime Minister, Boris Johnson leaves 10 Downing Street to take part in the weekly session of Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs) at the House of Commons on March 24, 2021 in London, England. This week marked one year since the UK first imposed lockdown measures to curb the spread of Covid-19. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)

The battle over lockdowns is still not over

The Covid Inquiry's pro-lockdown narrative is highly questionable

Lockdowns harmed our economy, mental health and national development

When will the political class consider the freedoms of those they purport to serve?

LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 24: Prime Minister, Boris Johnson leaves 10 Downing Street to take part in the weekly session of Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs) at the House of Commons on March 24, 2021 in London, England. This week marked one year since the UK first imposed lockdown measures to curb the spread of Covid-19. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)

Share this article

When Baroness Hallett published her Module 2 report of the Covid-19 Inquiry on 20 November, declaring that the government’s response was ‘too little, too late’ and that 23,000 lives could have been saved by locking down one week earlier, I found myself reflecting on the surreal years I spent as Head of Research for the Covid Recovery Group (CRG). Did we miss something? Has the £200 million inquiry found some evidence that we hadn’t countered that would dispel all of the arguments we made back then, and continue to make now? 

I then read the Module 2 report, and these reflective thoughts turned to outright anger. Again and again, the Inquiry included evidence and relied on modelling for its conclusions that the CRG, among other organisations, had disproved. The Inquiry has uncritically accepted the premise that earlier and harder lockdowns were the solution, ignoring the vast body of evidence suggesting the opposite. It has also failed to weigh up the full costs and consequences of lockdown restrictions. I am half-tempted to suggest an inquiry into the Covid Inquiry. 

While it had its moment in the spotlight, the report was quickly buried by the chaos in the run-up to and following the Budget. We cannot allow its conclusions to become our future pandemic policy: if we do, our society, economy and indeed, health, will suffer greatly.

In November 2020, Steve Baker and Mark Harper launched the CRG during the second national lockdown: throughout all of the Covid pandemic, we were the only organised parliamentary opposition to lockdown policy. The formation of the CRG followed the Brady Amendment in September 2020, which sought to ensure the House of Commons would debate and vote on any future coronavirus measures before they came into force. I was honoured to work on that effort and subsequently work for the CRG. Steve and Mark are heroes for what they did during the pandemic.

We met weekly with CRG member MPs, poring over the data, challenging the government’s modelling and producing briefings to arm backbenchers, and in many cases, supporting governments and ministers with the facts to push back against the pro-lockdown consensus. 

I cannot overstate the challenges we faced. The entire government machine pushed the pro-lockdown narrative, while the Labour Party either gave ministers a free pass or argued for harder and faster restrictions. There were heroes across the country who pushed back against lockdown restrictions, but in parliament, it was the CRG versus everybody.

I remember vividly one instance when the government was using a false argument about the furlough scheme to pressure MPs into voting for the renewal of the Coronavirus Act. After intense research with a staff member of the House of Commons Library, we discovered the Treasury’s lines were demonstrably false – its own communications and research departments, with all of their staff and resources, did not know that the lines ministers were repeating were incorrect. This is a microcosm of how even the government did not understand its own Covid laws and rules. We forced the government to change its position, allowing more MPs to vote against the renewal of the Act. It was only five of us who ran the CRG, fighting against the entire government apparatus, but we made a difference.

What strikes me most about the Inquiry’s findings is not its conclusions, but what it conspicuously omits. The Inquiry has uncritically accepted the premise that earlier and harder lockdowns were the solution. The headline claim – that 23,000 lives could have been saved – rests almost entirely on modelling by Professor Neil Ferguson’s team at Imperial College. Yet as Professor Simon Wood observed, it remains ‘unclear why the model-based claim that a week earlier lockdown could have saved 23,000 English lives should be considered any more credible than the same group’s model-based estimate that 35,000 lives in Sweden would be lost without a lockdown’. Sweden did not enter a mandatory lockdown. Its death toll was nowhere near what the models suggested. Sweden’s overall excess mortality from 2020-2022 was among the lowest in Europe.

Throughout the pandemic, Professor Carl Heneghan and his team at the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine consistently demonstrated the profound failures of the modelling relied on by the government for its response to Covid. When the government announced the second lockdown on October 31, 2020, one of the four models used – the Public Health England/Cambridge model – predicted 1,000 deaths on November 1. The actual number was just over 200 – wrong by a factor of five. Furthermore, there is evidence that Covid cases were actually falling before all three lockdowns were imposed. It seems the peak of infections had already passed as we entered the first, second, and third lockdowns. 

The Inquiry at least acknowledged that lockdowns ‘left enduring impacts on society, halted normal childhood experiences, delayed treatment for non-Covid health issues, worsened social inequalities, and significantly affected mental health’. Yet it made no serious attempt to quantify these harms against the modelled benefits. This was precisely what the CRG demanded throughout the pandemic. The non-Covid health harms were staggering: Breast Cancer Now estimated 986,000 women missed mammograms; Macmillan estimated 50,000 missing cancer diagnoses in 2020; domestic abuse calls ran 49% higher than normal; the British Heart Foundation estimated 5,000 excess deaths from heart problems during the first lockdown. This is not even to mention the many economic harms that lockdowns caused both during and after the pandemic.

When the government finally attempted a cost-benefit analysis, in response to CRG demands, we were sat in Steve’s office, ready for a very long evening dissecting the document. Within about 90 minutes, the wheels fell off. The analysis stated that ‘given the unprecedented nature of both the virus and the restrictions that have been required to mitigate it, it is not possible to assess the balance of these effects’. This is not how you implement successful policies, and at this point, we were deep into the pandemic so the government had no excuses for not being able to quantify its effects. Add to this that the government’s own earlier analysis from July 2020 had found that ‘the health impacts from a lockdown and lockdown-induced recession are greater in terms of QALYs than the direct COVID-19 deaths’. Their own analysis suggested lockdowns might have cost more life-years than they saved – and then they buried it.

A great frustration is that Mark Harper and Steve Baker were never called as witnesses, despite their unique perspective as leaders of the only organised parliamentary opposition. In March 2022, they wrote to Baroness Hallett offering evidence. They received no invitation. Meanwhile, SAGE members gave extensive testimony, and the overwhelming tenor of expert evidence was that restrictions should have come sooner and harder – the very premise we disproved. 

As Lord Frost wrote, the Inquiry has provided ‘nothing of value’ and merely reinforced the prevailing belief that lockdown restrictions were the only viable response. 

The Covid-19 Inquiry is a shambles. The evidence it has relied on has been disproven time and time again. If we follow the Covid-19 Inquiry’s conclusions, we will be less prepared, not better prepared, for the next pandemic. The lesson it tells us is this: lock down earlier and harder. But the evidence suggests the real lesson should be: consider the full costs of restrictions, challenge expert consensus and preserve the freedoms and livelihoods of the people you serve. We cannot allow the pro-lockdown narrative to win. The Inquiry is a reminder that the battle over lockdowns is not over.

This is an edited version of an essay published by Harry Richer for Voices for a Free Future. The full version is available here.

Share this article

Written by

Harry Richer is Director of Fighting for a Free Future.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.