Nimby Watch: Nimbys hate your children



In this edition of Nimby Watch, we take a trip to the quiet – very quiet – village of Chapel-en-le-Frith, in Derbyshire…
Okay, what brings us to the Peak District, then? Well, it’s a small town in an idyllic part of the country. For most people, that would be reason enough. For our purposes, it’s also exactly the sort of place that ends up getting incredibly worked up over relatively minor developments.
Yep, that sounds about right. So what’s the bone of contention this time? It’s a multi-use game area – what most of us would call a kids’ park – with a skate area, built in a park inside the small town as something for its kids and teens to do.
That sounds… good? Everyone is always complaining about kids spending too much time staring at screens, and with local authority cuts, youth clubs everywhere have closed and there’s often nothing at all for kids to do. Surely no one is trying to stop this being built? Well… I have good news and I have bad news.
Okay, fire away. Well, the good news is that after a fundraising effort from across the local community, the park actually got built in 2010, and was by all accounts actually quite widely used.
This is clearly going to end badly, then. Yep. It was demolished in October, after a years-long legal battle between the council and three local residents, ostensibly over the noise that came from the play area.
Hang on, people who lived near a public park objected to the sounds of children playing? Yes, yes they did. Or they eventually did, having tried all sorts of other grounds to complain about the park first. An earlier complaint centred around whether or not the park had been built slightly too close to existing structures, in breach of planning laws – but this one didn’t seem to get anywhere.
Wait, someone managed to make a complaint so petty they didn’t win even under UK planning laws? I was shocked too. But it turns out that it’s possible! After that, they moved on to complaining about antisocial behaviour – because inevitably any public facility that’s going to be used by children and teenagers will attract some amount of that. But this turned into something of a dead end too, at least when it came to civil action, because this had to be dealt with through the council’s antisocial behaviour powers.
These three residents had tried two different ways to stop the park being used, then? Why did noise prove to be more successful? Essentially, they complained that the noise the park generated was proving damaging to their health, because they were losing sleep – even though none of the many other residents living near the park had anything like this same problem.
Could a court not have suggested they buy earplugs for bedtime? Initially, one more or less did. At a first hearing in 2021, the judge threw out the case, saying that noise from the normal use of the park needed to be separated from noise caused by antisocial behaviour – and argued that it was the latter which had made the complainants ‘hyper-sensitive’. The judge essentially implied that the complaints about the noise of footballs hitting things were essentially a proxy for other objections to the park.
That sounds eminently sensible. Yes, it was, so of course it didn’t last. The case ended up at High Court in 2022, and was overturned – this time, the judge found that the two different causes of noise couldn’t be separated, and the complainants were entitled to a noise abatement order.
A ‘noise abatement order’? That sounds like they just wanted some sort of sound proofing or dampening to be put in place. Could all of this have been sorted reasonably? Not really. The 2022 case makes it very clear that the three residents at the heart of this case wanted the park to be torn down. The High Court tried to stop short of that measure, and give the council less drastic options – and pretty much left them to work it out between themselves.
How did that work out? Inevitably, they were back in court in November. The council had given up a month before and ripped up the park. As a result of this pre-emptive action, the court chose to limit the council’s fine to a nominal £100, but awarded costs to the complainants’ legal team totalling £130,000. The whole thing has cost the parish council so much that it’s had to increase its portion of locals’ council tax payments by 86%.
I imagine the complainants are very popular in the local area, then. I hope their newfound peace and quiet is worth it. Well, according to locals, one of them recently moved to a new home in a nearby city – so won’t even get to enjoy their victory firsthand. Other residents are understandably baffled and furious that they’ve lost a park and are paying a fortune in legal fees for the privilege.
Well, this is all thoroughly depressing. Yeah, I don’t really have a cheery kicker on this one. If Nimbyism doesn’t even stop once something’s built – and if a handful of local cranks have this many options at their disposal – they’re always going to win, and nothing will get done. Tweaking planning laws alone won’t be enough to tackle that. There’ll need to be much broader legal reform – and a culture change too, so that there’s no absolute right to a silent home.
And what are my kids supposed to do now? Well, it’s fine. They just can’t use any screens, can’t be at the park or youth group, but obviously they can’t congregate in the streets, because that’s antisocial. Really, they shouldn’t be seen or heard at any time. But also, we must have more of them. Sort it out, won’t you?