Andrew Lilico

Andrew Lilico is an economist and writer.

Articles

Brexit

What Rachel Reeves gets wrong about Brexit

Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been talking in recent days about Labour’s ambition to revise the UK’s trade deal with the EU. Closer alignment of regulation is a key part of that. One of Labour’s main ambitions, set out in its manifesto, is an agreement with the EU on veterinary regulations. But in Reeves’ view, […]

Economics

Labour doesn’t know what caused the 2008 financial crisis

The Labour Party has released a viral attack video called The Big Short: Rishi Sunak. This video uses an amusing variant of the famous scene from the 2015 movie ‘The Big Short’ with Margot Robbie in a bubble bath drinking champagne, only this time it is Jon Richardson drinking beer. The claim of the video […]

Economics

How to fix British banking

Wherever one sits on the political spectrum, a priority since the bank bailouts of 2007-2009 has been to try to prevent that situation from arising again. One kind of approach to achieving that has revolved around restriction and oversight. Tough capital and liquidity requirements, combined with strong regulatory oversight of lending on bank balance sheets, […]

Energy & Environment

A carbon border tax is a no brainer for free marketeers

Jeremy Hunt is planning to introduce a special tax on certain imports called a ‘carbon border adjustment mechanism’ (CBAM). Some Tory MPs say this is a bad idea, as does Liz Truss’ Growth Commission, a group of economists who estimated that the scheme will cost 1.5% of GDP over a five year period. Some politicians […]

Policy

We have a deficit of political will, and it is standing in the way of prosperity

The IFS Green Budget is, as ever, a treasure trove of ideas and data – far too many to address in one article. Predictions of unemployment rising to 5.8% next year – the highest for a decade. Estimates of how much this government’s tax threshold freezes will raise – some £52bn by 2027-28. And discussion […]

Economics

Sunak will struggle to hide behind falling inflation at the next election

Two key pieces of economic data have come out in recent days: the latest monetary growth data from the Bank of England and the latest house price data. The monetary data shows the contraction in broad money (M4ex, for those interested in the jargon) accelerating. It started contracting in July, for the first time since […]

Economics

On interest rates, the Bank of England’s ‘Goldilocksers’ have won the day

In a surprise move, the Bank of England has voted 5-4 to hold rates at 5.25%. Many financial market participants and monetary policy Kremlinologists had expected a rise to 5.5% but it was acknowledged as a knife-edge decision. There is a three-way split in current UK monetary policy thinking. The first camp (not represented on […]

Policy

The Stronger Towns Fund is gesture politics. And that is no bad thing

This morning Communities Secretary James Brokenshire announced £1.6bn for a Stronger Towns Fund. That is set to include £281m for the North-West, £212m for the West Midlands, £197m for Yorkshire and the Humber, £105m for the North-East and £110m for the East Midlands. Much smaller sums would be available for southern English regions. Regional policy […]

Brexit

Austerity may be on hold, but it isn’t over

In 2018 the government made three significant attempts to declare that the “age of austerity” most famously associated with George Osborne was finally at an end. Spin around the Spring Budget, a speech in October by Theresa May, and the Autumn Budget all declared austerity nearing its end. Unfortunately, however, in the case of the […]

Brexit

May must go

It’s time for May to go. Both Party and country are drifting, possibly to disaster, and she is simply incapable, any more, of leading us anywhere. If she is kept in place this evening, that means she is in place for another year — in place through Brexit if that happens on time; in place […]

Brexit

Brexiteers should hold their nerve and set a course for No Deal

This morning CapX editor Oliver Wiseman argued that “Brexiteers are snatching defeat from the jaws of victory” by urging that May’s deal be voted down. This is one of the main arguments proffered by that few, that happy few, that band of Brexit brothers that believes May’s deal is the only way forward that “saves […]

Brexit

The Bank of England’s Brexit forecasts aren’t just wrong. They’re absurd

Yesterday the Bank of England published its latest Brexit analysis. The scenarios the Bank paints include some that are lurid, wild and absurd, and, of course, it is those scenarios that have attracted all the headlines. In particular, the Bank’s scenario for a disorderly no deal Brexit has GDP contracting 8 per cent in a […]

Brexit

No deal is better than this deal

Just as the fine print can make an apparently good deal into a bad one, it can also do the reverse. The Cabinet apparently has a few hours to read through 500 pages of fine print, without any outside scrutiny or analysis, before today’s cabinet meeting. The chances they will have the foggiest idea what […]

Mark Carney has made mistakes – but the rot goes back further

This week’s papers have not made easy reading for Bank of England governor Mark Carney. His former colleague Andrew Sentance, the Monetary Policy Committee’s best known hawk of recent years (he voted unsuccessfully for interest rate rises at each of his last 12 MPC meetings), told the Times that Carney has made the Bank “timid” […]

Taxation

Bad jokes, not much Brexit and just enough politics – a job well done for Fiscal Phil

Well, the 2018 Budget was not quite as much of a non-event as many had forecast. Stronger than expected tax revenues and slightly faster growth provided Philip Hammond with a little extra wriggle room, and he gave himself even more by deciding not to balance the budget. That allowed him to meet the £20bn NHS […]

Policy

Beyond the platitudes, John McDonnell’s true aims are increasingly clear

The Shadow Chancellor delivered his pre-Budget speech today. John McDonnell usually manages to include in his speeches one or two interesting-if-horribly-destructive new policy ideas. One might have assumed a pre-Budget speech would be the occasion for a few more. But McDonnell kept his focus firmly on established ground. Most of McDonnell’s speech was political and […]

Health

Does the patent system need fixing?

Patents are a rather controversial topic among pro-market thinkers. Some are very much in favour of them, seeing intellectual property as just another kind of property and as entitled to legal protection as any other. Others see patents as government-sponsored market power, a latter-day version of the ancient Chinese salt monopoly. The main argument in […]

Policy

Austerity isn’t over – not by a long chalk

In one of the more widely-discussed passages of her Conservative Party Conference speech, Theresa May said “a decade after the financial crash, people need to know that the austerity it led to is over and that their hard work has paid off.” It’s not altogether apparent what she means by suggesting that austerity is over, […]

Business

Jeremy Corbyn, Gordon Gekko and the morality of markets

In his speech at Labour Party Conference this afternoon, Jeremy Corbyn said, “Ten years ago this month, the whole edifice of greed-is-good, deregulated financial capitalism, lauded for a generation as the only way to run a modern economy, came crashing to earth, with devastating consequences.” As every pedant knows, “Greed is good” was not a […]

Business

Cheering Wonga’s demise misses the point about payday lending

In some quarters, there is some jollity and satisfaction with the woes Wonga now faces, with administration and the break-up of its loan book. Perhaps Wonga has indeed mis-sold its products to large numbers of consumers and deserves what has come its way. But more broadly we should be careful before being too joyous about […]