Photo: Getty Images

With the right changes, we can make Whitehall effective again

The British state has proven that it has the capacity to perform

We can transform the machinery of government if civil servants heed the laws of good leadership

For each beacon of state success, there are sadly dozens of failures

Photo: Getty Images

Share this article

First some good news for once: there are a surprising number of areas where the UK government has achieved outstanding results, more or less on time and on budget. Here are half a dozen examples: 

Not surprisingly, these bits of government all share the principles of good management: a strong vision of what they want to achieve, a long-term outlook, stability of management, clear objectives and plans on how to achieve them, independence from political interference, robust reporting and accountability and minimal bureaucracy.

But now for the bad news. For each beacon of state success, there are sadly dozens of failures. So for Thames Tideway Tunnel, remember HS2. For Nick Gibb at the Department for Education for ten years, think of the 14 prison ministers appointed since 2010. For the Vaccine Task Force, be outraged at the scandals of PPE procurement. For the five-day turnaround at the Passport Office, compare the average 24-week wait in London to get a driving test appointment. For NICE, remember endlessly repeated MoD procurement failures, endangering the lives and wellbeing of tens of thousands of servicemen and women. 

And it gets worse. For everyone in government – politicians and senior civil servants alike – knows that they should learn and apply the lessons of success. After all, in almost every single one of the 17 major reports into government efficacy since Fulton in 1968, they call for the lessons of success to be shared widely across government.

But they never are. Lessons remain unlearnt. 

Why? At its simplest, the machinery of Whitehall – and the public services – has neither the capability nor the incentive to react and learn from both success and failure. Unlike the private sector, where competitive pressures oblige (and reward) managers to take risks and to innovate constantly, Whitehall and the public services have little such pressure. Why rock the boat? Why be difficult? 

So what can be done? It would be pointless to launch yet another review, peopled by the Great and Good, attempting to find the levers to pull to reform the heart of government. If that were what was needed, then the 17 previous attempts would surely have led to significant change.

It is time, rather, for a far more ambitious and radical transformation of the machinery of government, one that recognises that the way in which a policy is implemented is just as important as the policy itself; that results and accountability are what matters, not process. And that real rewards should flow to those who can demonstrate that their initiatives have brought tangible improvements to outcomes.

And to finish with some good news: among senior politicians and civil servants of all political persuasions, there is real appetite for change. And the reward for taking this on would be huge, both in improved public services and in productivity: £80bn a year according to the accountancy firm EY. So, Rachel, Kemi or Nigel, why not?

Sign up to the Effective Governance Forum’s newsletter here.

Share this article

Written by

Tim Knox
Tim Knox is the editor of the Effective Governance Forum.

CapX depends on the generosity of its readers.

If you value what we do, please consider making a donation.

Amount
Period

Your message has not been sent.